Detecting Lateral Movement via WinRM Using KQL
Over the past few months we’ve been looking a little more into the detection methods we might use to identify strange activity within a given environment.
A lot of this research stems from questions asked by our clients following a technical engagement, or questions from students that have taken our Hacking Enterprises training. With the arrival of our new Defending Enterprises training this year where we look at detection methods from our ‘Top 10 in-the-field attacks’, a lot of this research naturally evolved and we found this element particularly interesting.
Microsoft Azure Sentinel is fast becoming our go-to SIEM as it not only brings the accessibility of cloud services, but a wealth of functionality at a relatively low price point. In this blog we’re going to take a brief look at the power of the Kusto Query Language (KQL).
Detecting Lateral Movement Through WinRM
Under the context of internal network monitoring, we wanted a quick and easy method to identify when a WinRM or PowerShell Remoting session had been instigated, but we also wanted an idea of where the user both had originated from, and targeted. As PowerShell Remoting uses WinRM to establish connections, the same Indictor of Attack (IOA) could be used.
When a WinRM connection is initialised EventID 6 will be recorded (the source host) and when a WinRM connection is received EventID 91 is recorded (the target host). Both events will be logged in Microsoft-Windows-WinRM/Operational (Windows Remote Management through the GUI).
Therefore, to chain together such events we can use a Time Window Join operation to map source > target using a query such as the following:
Event | where EventID == 6 | where Source == "Microsoft-Windows-WinRM" | project SourceEvent = EventID, SourceTime=TimeGenerated, UserName, SourceComputer = Computer | join kind=inner ( Event | where EventID == 91 | where Source == "Microsoft-Windows-WinRM" | project TargetEvent = EventID, TargetTime=TimeGenerated, UserName, TargetComputer = Computer ) on UserName | where (TargetTime - SourceTime) between (0min .. 1min) | project SourceEvent, TargetEvent, SourceComputer, TargetComputer, UserName, SourceTime, TargetTime | sort by SourceTime desc
In short, this query will look for Event ID 6 in the Microsoft-Windows-WinRM log and, if found, a second query is executed that looks for Event ID 91, again in the Microsoft-Windows-WinRM log, but the events have to occur within 1 minute of each other (in larger, busy environments this timing may need to be tuned). If both events are identified (matched on username), details of the event are displayed, as shown in the example below.
Identifying Further Activity Through PowerShell Logging
We can further investigate any activities by collating EventID 91 (a WinRM connection has been received – i.e. the target host) with PowerShell logging EventID 4103 (Module Logging), to see what may have been executed after the connection was made.
Event | where EventID == 91 | where Source == "Microsoft-Windows-WinRM" | project SourceEvent = EventID, SourceTime=TimeGenerated, UserName, Computer | join kind=inner ( Event | where EventID == 4103 | where Source == "Microsoft-Windows-PowerShell" | project TargetEvent = EventID, TargetTime=TimeGenerated, UserName, Computer, RenderedDescription ) on Computer | where (TargetTime - SourceTime) between (0min .. 1min) | project SourceEvent, TargetEvent, Computer, RenderedDescription , UserName, SourceTime, TargetTime | sort by SourceTime desc
As per the previous query, we’re using a join statement with much of the same underlying logic. In this instance if Event ID 91 is identified, a second query is executed that looks for Event ID 4103 within 1 minute of the initial connection. If both events are identified, details are displayed, as shown in the example below.
We always recommend establishing a decent baseline to know what normal activity looks like before diving into trying to identify the abnormal, otherwise it becomes a very difficult task to spot the haystack let alone the needle!
If this has grabbed your interest, why not attend our FREE ‘Catch me if you can – Seeing the red through the blue’ workshop at Wild West Hackin’ Fest this coming June.